|
|
Rank: Member
Groups: Team Gladiators
Joined: 4/13/2008
Posts: 2,225
Location: St Heliers, Auckland, NZ
|
I control face-up GK descendant.
I have soul exchange in my hand. I want to play soul exchange, tribute an opponents monster for the effect of Descendant and then destroy another card with descendants effect.
I can only do this if
A) I control another GK monster
B) I control another GK monster and the opponents monster I am tributing is also a GK monster
C) The opponents monster I am tributing is a GK monster, and I control no other monsters
D) I don't need to control any other monster and it doesn't matter what the opponents monster I am tributing is
E) This doesnt work
which of the 5 options work?
(It can be more than one, I guess)
I'm guessing that only B and C work but I just wanted to check
Soul Exchange
Select 1 monster your opponent controls. This turn you can Tribute that monster as if you controlled it. You cannot conduct your Battle Phase the turn you activate this card.
Gravekeeper's Descendant:
You can Tribute 1 face-up "Gravekeeper's" monster you control, except this card, to destroy 1 card your opponent controls.
Liam Fisher
TRUSTED TRADERS: D4nzyg, Batman84, Nightassailant23, HappyChappy, Slayer TY, SuperOwnag3, Haou Judai, Triple S, Mr Amazing, Athrun, Yuki-o, Genis, Fusilier25, xDanELx, Maniczxc123, planeswalkerzen, kithkindude, DarK_FienD, James_Pineapple, Drunk_Brother, Silver, MasterPowell, TimmyShock, lawrence.l
|
|
Rank: Member
Groups: Dragon Duelist, Member
Joined: 9/5/2009
Posts: 518
Location: Hawke's Bay
|
firehex wrote:I control face-up GK descendant.
I have soul exchange in my hand. I want to play soul exchange, tribute an opponents monster for the effect of Descendant and then destroy another card with descendants effect.
I can only do this if
A) I control another GK monster
B) I control another GK monster and the opponents monster I am tributing is also a GK monster
C) The opponents monster I am tributing is a GK monster, and I control no other monsters
D) I don't need to control any other monster and it doesn't matter what the opponents monster I am tributing is
E) This doesnt work
which of the 5 options work?
(It can be more than one, I guess)
I'm guessing that only B and C work but I just wanted to check
Soul Exchange
Select 1 monster your opponent controls. This turn you can Tribute that monster as if you controlled it. You cannot conduct your Battle Phase the turn you activate this card.
Gravekeeper's Descendant:
You can Tribute 1 face-up "Gravekeeper's" monster you control, except this card, to destroy 1 card your opponent controls. it works if they gt a spy or something .like u can soul 4 a substitoad effect
Micheal Hancock
Current Decks: flamvell cat
2ND DRAGON DUELS 2010
what if i were to TECH 7 BLUE EYES WHITE DRAGON
http://forums.gameplayer.co.nz/Default.aspx?g=posts&t=24708&find=unread
|
|
Rank: Member
Groups: Sparta
Joined: 1/25/2007
Posts: 1,284
Location: Waiwera, Nth Auckland
|
Interesting.
I looked up Soul Exchange and it reads differently to yours
"Select 1 monster your opponent controls. This turn, if you would Tribute a monster you control, Tribute the selected monster instead. You cannot conduct your Battle Phase during the turn that you activate this card."
By this text I believe you can Soul Exchange and tribute a non Gravekeeper so long as you have a GK face up other than Descendant. I mean, it specifies that if you would tribute a monster you control (a GK Spy and legal tribute) you may tribute the selected monster instead (ie. whatever you targeted).
Soul Exchange makes no mention as to whether this targeted card has to be a legal target for the tribute in question?
By the text on your Soul Exchange it seems as though this is not possible - unless it was a GK.
Well that's my two cents...now we need a judge 
We know,
Girls = Money x Time
We also know that Time is Money.
Thus,
Girls = Money x Money = (Money)^2
We also know that Money is the root of evil.
i.e. Money = root(Evil).
And therefore,
(Money)^2 = Evil = Girls.
|
|
Rank: Member
Groups: Dragon Duelist, Member
Joined: 9/5/2009
Posts: 518
Location: Hawke's Bay
|
Voidshard wrote:Interesting. I looked up Soul Exchange and it reads differently to yours "Select 1 monster your opponent controls. This turn, if you would Tribute a monster you control, Tribute the selected monster instead. You cannot conduct your Battle Phase during the turn that you activate this card." By this text I believe you can Soul Exchange and tribute a non Gravekeeper so long as you have a GK face up other than Descendant. I mean, it specifies that if you would tribute a monster you control (a GK Spy and legal tribute) you may tribute the selected monster instead (ie. whatever you targeted). Soul Exchange makes no mention as to whether this targeted card has to be a legal target for the tribute in question? By the text on your Soul Exchange it seems as though this is not possible - unless it was a GK. Well that's my two cents...now we need a judge i thought if it was a gk u could tribute it straight up ne ways
Micheal Hancock
Current Decks: flamvell cat
2ND DRAGON DUELS 2010
what if i were to TECH 7 BLUE EYES WHITE DRAGON
http://forums.gameplayer.co.nz/Default.aspx?g=posts&t=24708&find=unread
|
|
Rank: Member
Groups: Dragon Duelist, Team Assailant
Joined: 10/14/2009
Posts: 1,266
|
dont htink u can coz it says GK monster that you control but if soul exchange it, ur op still controls it
TRUSTED TRADERS: ReCkZtA,pureshzl,Kenbee,MR.LMAO,God)Squall,elemental hero scared heart,yugioh_girl_duelist_person,x Holden Baby x,yu-gi-oh_master,Naru,Luxtar23,Rogue,RaV3NoUs14, David_The_Great,NightAssailant23
Top 16 ~ 2010 Nats (6-2 Deus Ex Machina)
Quote:Quote:Oi Boss, You Know We're Not Actually In America Right? Quote:I Don't Understand A Word You Just Said, Try Speaking American. It's The Only Language I Understand
|
|
Rank: Member
Groups: Member
Joined: 1/25/2007
Posts: 796
|
B and C are fine
|
|
|
Guest |